(photo: Veluben)
02.03.2021, 11:54

Facebook Facing Unsafe Working Practices Lawsuits

Health, Safety, Security & Environment, Technology, Workplace Technology

Thirty content moderators who claim their mental health was harmed as a result of exposure to toxic visual content are suing Facebook and recruitment agencies, CPL Solutions, Accenture, Majorel and CCC.


The moderators from Ireland, Germany and Spain have filed their lawsuit with the Irish High Court in Dublin claiming that they took on community moderation roles with inadequate training and no access to psychiatrists and that their working conditions resulted in severe mental trauma which left some moderators feeling suicidal. 


The first case was brought before the Irish High Court in December 2019 by Chris Gray, a former community operations analyst at Facebook, who was recruited by CPL Solutions. His case is being handled by Coleman Legal Partners who have filed a complaint that Gray was expected to review up to 600 pieces of content every shift and was under intense pressure to achieve an accuracy rate of 98 per cent, to avoid erroneously removing content that did not contravene Facebook’s community guidelines. This required him to scrutinise graphic footage including child sexual abuse, fatal beatings, executions and torture.


Twenty nine more moderators have subsequently filed similar lawsuits with the Irish High Court, claiming that images that they witnessed in the course of their duties have injured their mental health. 


Crispin Pikes, CEO of Image Analyzer which provides a solution for filtering out harmful online images and video, says: "Back in 2019 when the first moderator brought his case to the High Court in Dublin, employee rights advocate, Foxglove, compared Facebook’s community moderation system to an unsafe factory floor, where workers are being recklessly exposed to an injurious working environment. This is precisely what this is.


"We have known since the first world war that continuous exposure to violent and disturbing images can cause chronic damage to people’s mental health. The Lancet first wrote about post-traumatic stress disorder in soldiers returning from the front in 1915. More than a hundred years later, we’re still seeing employees being sent into the trenches to defend the general public against viewing toxic images on major social media platforms. I’m particularly disheartened to hear that human moderators are expected to act like robots and achieve a 98 per cent accuracy rate, when this could be achieved by technology leaving only the most nuanced images to be reviewed by human moderators.


"This issue is now going across jurisdictions, with moderators in Ireland, Germany and Spain coming forward to report that they have been injured by being required to wade through toxic content for extended periods. In addition, third party agencies that recruit staff for organisations that fail to safeguard their employees’ mental health and safety are being exposed to litigation.


In the UK and Europe new regulations are coming in the form of the Online Safety Bill and the European Digital Services Act. Any organisation that enables users to upload visual content should be watching this case with interest as, under new regulations, all interactive website operators will have a legal duty of care to remove harmful content from their websites. However, as this case demonstrates, relying on humans to clean up toxic content is not in the spirit or intent of these laws."


Article rating:

vote data

Leave a reply

Escalator at Tower Gateway DLR station in London. (photo: Chris McKenna)
News Editor  - 23.03.2021

Lift and Escalator Maintenance at London DLR Stations

PropTech provider WeMaintain has signed a four-year contract with KeolisAmey Docklands (KAD) for the provision of lift and escalator maintenance solutions to all London Docklands Light Railway...

Members of the express testing team. (photo: ABM Industries Inc)
News Editor  - 23.03.2021

Partnership to Support UK Covid-19 Express Testing

ABM has partnered with Cignpost Diagnostics to provide 250 trained team members to service the manpower needs at COVID-19 testing sites at Heathrow, Gatwick and Edinburgh airports.

Holding a mirror up to the industry: Jeff Dewing, Cloudfm CEO. (photo: Cloudfm Group)
News Editor  - 31.03.2021

Exposing Widespread FM Failures in the UK

A potentially explosive book by Cloudfm CEO, Jeff Dewing, contains allegations of widespread corporate failings in the UK's £120 billion market for facilities management services.

Mike Winter, managing director of MIW Water Coolers. (photo: Made Blue)
News Editor  - 22.03.2021

Saving Plastic and Lives

On World Water Day, Dutch charity Made Blue and MIW have launched a water fountain offering UK consumers the option to donate 75p via a QR code to clean water projects in developing countries.

 (photo: Spie UK)
News Editor  - 19.04.2021

High Voltage Switchgear Contract

Merseytravel, the strategic transport advisor to the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority, has awarded SPIE UK a new contract for the supply and installation of replacement high voltage...

 (photo: Michael Taylor)
News Editor  - 16.04.2021

Leeds Relocation Contract

Commercial relocation specialist Business Moves Group (BMG) has been selected to deliver a relocation contract by Leeds Building Society, the UK's fifth largest building society which dates from 1875.